Just back from one week in Montauk- Restaurants

We just returned from a week in Montauk and I wanted to post our restaurant experiences.

Oyster Pond - Had a really nice meal with huge portions. Fish cooked perfectly, service very good. 3 stars

ENE - Good but not as great as in the past. All dishes designed to share. Creative selections. In the past we had ';to die for'; meals here but now just good. 2 and 1/2 stars

Fishbar - A new place, small menu but truly excellent. Great views, not packed with screaming kids as every other meal we had was. Excellent fish and italian style fare. 4 stars

Westlake Clam House - This place was highly recommended but I am not sure why. Food really had no taste. We were three, eating different entree%26#39;s but all had no flavor. No stars

Lunch aka Lobster Roll - An old standard for lunches and fried dinners. 3 stars in its category

Just my opinion,

Esther in Cooperstown, NY

Just back from one week in Montauk- Restaurants

Ester, glad you had a good time in montauk (one of my favorite places... (lobster roll is SUCH an institution, right?) but I actually have a question for you since you are listed from cooperstown.

my husband is dying to get there and see, of course, the bb hall of fame... do you have any tips.. any good hotels near there? thanks for any help..

stacy from long island.

Just back from one week in Montauk- Restaurants

Hi Stacy,

the biggest tip for visiting Cooperstown is to come after Labor Day when the crowds diminish and everything is still open. Lots of B and B%26#39;s, a fancy hotel, Motels on the lake. Feel awkward talking too much about Cooperstown on this thread so get me your email address and i will send a private note.

-Esther

thanks so much.. kennedy6@optonline.net

Inlet Cafe on East Lake Drive, brand new with extensive menu seafood/asian dishes..Fantastic Sunset. If you have a long wait you simply go to the bar get your cocktail and wait for the most briliant sunset.

make up